1. Start with the amount
A hardware wallet makes the most sense when your crypto holdings are large enough that losing them would actually hurt. Rule of thumb: if you own more than a couple of months of salary in crypto, it belongs on a hardware wallet, not on an exchange.
For a few hundred euros in Bitcoin, do not bother spending the same on hardware. For ten thousand euros and up, the wallet is cheap insurance.
2. Bitcoin-only or multi-coin?
If you only own Bitcoin, pick a Bitcoin-only device. Less code on the device means less attack surface. Coldcard Mk5 and the BitBox02 in Bitcoin-only edition are the obvious picks.
If you also own Ethereum, Solana or anything else, you need a multi-coin device. Ledger Nano S Plus and Trezor Safe 3 are both solid in the cheap tier.
3. Open source or closed source?
Trezor, BitBox and Coldcard ship fully open source firmware, which means independent researchers can audit the code. Ledger keeps its firmware closed but reaches certifications such as CC EAL6+ at the chip level instead.
Both approaches have a zero-track-record of compromised private keys to date. Pick the philosophical starting point you prefer, not one that is supposedly safer than the other.
4. How much screen do you actually need?
The small OLED screen on a Nano S Plus or Safe 3 is fine for signing the occasional transaction. If you reach for your wallet often, the small screen quickly becomes frustrating, because long addresses scroll across multiple frames.
In that case, a touchscreen model is worth the price: Ledger Flex, Trezor Safe 5 and Ledger Stax all show the entire transaction in one view, which makes Clear Signing far easier and removes a major source of mistakes.
5. iPhone or not?
To sign transactions from an iPhone, you need a device with Bluetooth or NFC: Ledger Nano X, Flex, Stax, Trezor Safe 5 (limited) or the new BitBox02 Nova. The classic BitBox02, Coldcard Mk5 and Trezor Safe 3 are primarily desktop and Android devices.
6. Where do you buy?
Direct from the manufacturer is always the first choice. The second choice is an authorized reseller. Never buy on Amazon Marketplace or eBay, where there are documented cases of devices with compromised seeds.
Manufacturers ship with a tamper-evident seal. If the seal is broken or looks different from the manufacturer's website pictures, return the unit unopened.
7. Setup routine, every time
- Unpack the device and check that the seal is intact.
- Update firmware via the manufacturer's own app (Ledger Wallet, Trezor Suite, BitBoxApp).
- Generate a new seed on the device, never from memory.
- Write the seed on paper (or a steel plate), never digitally.
- Test recovery with a small amount before sending the real funds.
The last point matters most. A seed you think you have but have not tested is not a seed.